Jessica Lange as Elsa Mars, German who runs a freak show in Jupiter, Florida, in the 1950s (pic ). 4th season.Sarah Paulson as Bette and Dot Tattler, two-headed conjoined twins who share one body (pic ). 4th season.Kathy Bates as Ethel Darling, freak show performer, ex-wife to Chiklis and mother of Evan Peters . 2nd season.Michael Chiklis as strongman Wendell del Toledo, husband to Angela Bassett and father of Peters. 1st season.Evan Peters as Jimmy Darling, the Lobster Boy (pic ), presumably based on Grady Stiles . 4th season.Angela Bassett as Desiree Dupree, freak show performer, wife of Chiklis. 2nd season.Denis O’Hare as Lange’s enemy, a “collector” of freaks. 3rd season.Frances Conroy as Matilda Hapschatt, freak show performer. 4th season.Jami e Brewer as Katie. 3rd season.Gabourey Sidibe as Patricia. 2nd season.Emma Roberts as Maggie. 2nd season.Wes Bentley as Eddie, a vengeful nemesis from Bates’ past. 1st season.Naomi Grossman as Pepper , her Schlitze -inspired character from season 2 (Asylum). 2nd season.Ben Woolf , who played the freakish Infantata (pic ) in season 1 (Murder House), as Meep. 2nd season.Erika Ervin (Guinness ’s world’s tallest professional model at over 6'7”) as Amazon Eve. 1st season.Christopher Neiman as Salty. 1st season.Ann McKenzie as Eudora Tattler, presumable relative of Bette/Dot. 1st season.Ramona Tyler as Mildred Bachman. She appeared in one episode of Coven. 2nd season.Mariana Paola Vicente as Carol, she was Puerto Rico’s Miss Universe candidate in 2010. 1st season.Rose Siggins (pic ) as Legless Suzi. 1st season.Grace Gummer as Penny, the candy striper. Daughter of Meryl Streep, she played Millie in a Coven episode (pic ). 2nd season.Mat Fraser as Paul, the illustrated man. 1st season.